I didn’t insult you other than to say that you’re biased, which I don’t think is an insult personally. I’m biased too, about different things. All humans are.

My point, for the third (3rd) time, is that having Harry be interested in being a cop is not out of character and poor writing because Harry’s traits and background don’t preclude him from an interest in being one.

I think you just don’t understand that cops come from the same schools, communities, homes, families, etc. as anyone else, including you; in other words, you have a significant mental rift that makes it impossible for you to walk the bridge of logic I built for you.

I don’t know if I can build a bridge big enough for you to cross. I guess just stare at my previous comment for a while until it clicks.

TL;DR: If you think, and even shout from the rooftops, that the only people suitable for law enforcement are pieces of shit, guess who is going to become law enforcement? Oh my, we seem to have a Too Many Pieces of Shit in Law Enforcement problem! Wonder how that happened…

I agree, but unless you’re asserting Harry did that, I don’t understand why you brought that up.

I haven’t touched the series in quite a long time, so you could be making specific references to specific things he did for all I know.

The nice part about my idea is that even with those hurdles in mind, I still proposed it knowing that all it would take is one person to happen upon whichever post or subreddit to auto-scrape and get the discussion on Lemmy going.

Let’s be real; 99% of the reason Lemmy is less popular than Reddit is copy+pasting a link, writing your own title, etc. is more effort than 0, therefore the Lemmy-Reddit hybrids like myself don’t bother.

Hell, even the staunchly anti-Reddit Lemmites who could be parasitically “stealing” posts and comments to steal Reddit’s thunder don’t do it. There are other things they’d rather do, evidently.

Now that I think of it, after using the word “scrape,” it could be that Reddit ToS follows most websites’ in that scraping is explicitly forbidden, so displaying the open source code (or even using it) would incur legal action from Reddit.

Of course not. That’s why I said “To the best of my recollection the last I’ve seen bits of traffic data here and there, […]”

To moderators. I want to say even to regular users if your comment/post gets enough traction on New Reddit, i.e. hundreds or thousands of views.

Other, similar websites also show such data to those in privileged positions as well. If they’re pretty sure you’re not a bot, they give it freely. Whatever tier above “average user” and especially “a person interested in growing the website out of self-interest” a given website has, it’ll probably be available. I’m sure you can imagine a half dozen that are on the money.

To the best of my recollection the last I’ve seen bits of traffic data here and there, it’s large, but not large in comparison to the US and India.

Fair enough, but that argument also works against you:

Why become a cop? He has other interests than being a cop.

is equal to

Why not become a cop? He’s interested in being a cop.

Surely you know cops don’t eat sleep and breathe law enforcement too, right? As in they have other hobbies and interests? That goes for every job; a tailor has hobbies other than tailoring, and a taxi driver has other interests than driving.

True, Harry’s (culture) is not morally perfect, and his morality is tainted by the writer’s perspective. I’m going with broad strokes here, and “he’s not perfect,” does not disqualify him for law enforcement IMO.

Fair enough, it was an implication that you might not have intended. Add to it that 99% of Lemmites believe “ACAB,” and you can imagine why I made that conclusion.

Here’s my Amateur Coder waving the Wand of Coding idea:

What if we had a FOSS browser extension that scraped Reddit passively, uploading everything you see as you browse (except PII like your username and PMs and such) via bot to Lemmy (on a delay so they can’t pinpoint your identity as easily?)

I can’t be the only one who splits their time between Lemmy and Reddit, and would much rather participate here than there, but there’s much less to comment on here.

My favorite subreddit (/r/tampa) recently perma-banned me for extremely petty reasons, but /c/tampa is a ghost town.

Reddit would probably sooner just lop off their entire EU userbase than comply.

No offense to Europeans because I love y’all, but you are a drop in the bucket for global (English) internet usage.

I really don’t know if what you state is accurate because I don’t recall from reading the books or watching the movies, so I can’t really comment on your prediction, and honestly we’re so far off-topic I’m barely interested in developing an opinion on it.

I just generally disagree with “Fred and George were better contributors to the resistance than the Trio,” for reasons stated above.

Again, cart before horse.

You’re asserting that there are no helpful cops, therefore Harry being helpful means he should not be a cop.

In reality, Harry being helpful should be a cop, because he could be in a position to help people.

Dexter/Batman don’t do a lot of helping, they just crack skulls of people they perceive as bad. Ironically for your point, much like most IRL cops.

True, but if we’re assigning roles via broad strokes as a proportion of their contributions, Fred and George were propagandists/saboteurs/etc. and Harry ‘n’ Co. were direct action.

Doing a quick propaganda as a trigger-puller doesn’t mean you’re now a propagandist, nor does doing a quick gunshot mean you’re now a fighter.

Again, Fred and George were vital elements, but (90%) Support is not more important than Fighting.

Everyone does that. It’s not a nazi thing.

It just currently (and historically) behooves nazis to do it as much as possible because it helps them recruit to their counter-culture movement.

Lemmy’s not that computer science oriented any more, much like Reddit.

This community specifically is a comics community, and this comic is about a very mainstream fiction series. Can’t get much more normie than that.

One concern seemingly nobody is discussing here is:

Is Harry a good person?

If so, and he’s good at the things you state (and especially if he’s only good at the things you state), why should he not be a cop?

You can’t really have a resistance without support like Fred and George and fighters like Harry.

A resistance with only supporters isn’t a resistance; it’s blogging.

I think we’re putting the cart before the horse here.

Assuming Harry is virtuous and good and brave and excellent at fighting dark wizards and helping people, wouldn’t that be the perfect person to become a cop?