- cross-posted to:
- world@quokk.au
- cross-posted to:
- world@quokk.au
You must log in or # to comment.
Look at who funded and lobbied for this, this isn’t about protecting EU manufacturing, most of these companies manufacture their goods outside the EU and charge exorbitant prices for them.
This is once again taking the power out of the proles hands.
Parent Corporate Member Key Retail Brands & Subsidiaries Annual Revenue Schwarz Group Lidl, Kaufland, PreZero €185.6 Billion REWE Group BILLA, REWE, Penny, Toom Baumarkt, BIPA €100.4 Billion Ahold Delhaize Albert Heijn, Delhaize, Alfa Beta, Mega Image, Maxi, Albert €92.35 Billion Carrefour Group Carrefour, Carrefour Market, Express, Atacadão, Cora, Match €91.48 Billion Tesco PLC Tesco, Tesco Express, One Stop €82 Billion Inditex Zara, Pull&Bear, Massimo Dutti, Bershka, Stradivarius €36 Billion H&M Group H&M, COS, Monki, Weekday, & Other Stories, ARKET €21 Billion Colruyt Group Colruyt, Okay, Spar €11.19 Billion Credit to https://www.reddit.com/user/Interesting_Pie_319/ for the data.
https://www.reddit.com/r/Aliexpress/comments/1ugpyoe/i_dug_around_a_bit_and_found_exactly_who_is/
The difference is that these companies have to adhere to EU regulations, e.g. on harmful chemicals. Cheap Chinese products famously do not, often times to an absurd degree, exceeding limits by thousands of times.
All companies selling in the EU market have to adhere to the General Product Safety Regulation even if the product and vendor is Chinese. The problem here is not the law, but enforcing the law.
Then regulate the products and impose fines?
and not forget sites like temu burn money to sell this stuff cheap while these have to actually run a profitable business. But 100 Billion Alibaba and 50 Billion Temu are the good guys in this, i guess
Important bit of information: China gets subsidised parcel fee under an agreement of the World Post Association. They pay less for postage than European businesses shipping within the continent.
Why is this not changed? Why all these additional taxes and hoops when they could simply cancels these subsidies?
They’re implicit subsidies.
So here it goes: there’s an international treaty saying basically “if a letter from your country is delivered in my contry, I’ll deliver it for free and vice versa”. So, you pay your national post some “international handling” so they e.g. deliver it to China, but in China the national post is now responsible for distribution and last mile for free, they don’t see a part of your postage.
So it’s subsidized now by the Chinese post basically: they only charge cents for “international shipping” to their citizens and businesses, last mile is handled for free from the local national post offices.
That system obviously was designed to work frictionless and easy in a time, where there was no globalized market to speak of.
It’s not so easy to reform and just cancel it might be a disadvantage as well: then all your other mailing stuff needs renegotiating as well. Just imagine the horror in canceling the treaty, and then you need to sit down with dealmaker Trump who sees an opportunity in order to get the US Post to handle your mail 😱
Good question. I guess you have to ask those responsible.
easier to add a new agreement than cancel an old i guess. treaties are hard
I’ve wondered for years how they manage free shipping for all the small shit.
e-commerce in Europe is laughably bad no wonder people are turning to Temu and China and abroad in general. It’s either Amazon or outdated brick stores with their own archaic tech that works sometimes, and surprises you with a couple extra fees every single checkout.
The only redemption right now is Shopify rollout for boosting small shops which is hard to mess up but even that is being overtaken by scam spam.
The service is just so bad that people will wait 2 weeks for potentially dangerous products and deal with customs just to save cup of coffee worth of money. The service is the issue not anything else.
I use Aliexpress because half the products on amazon are just dropshipper that buy from Aliexpress anyway. Why should I pay more for the same product? But there are genuinely good e-commerce in Europe that sells local products (Zalando for example)
This is where the DIY electronics hobbyist scene in the EU dies.
Good going corpos, you win. I’ll just consume your media and goon at home.
The only people that can import cheap Chinese stuff are corporations… don’t you dare bypassing their money making schemes
No, that’s a very naive and uninformed viewpoint. The EU is being flooding with 100s of millions of packages with value-free SHEIN and temu stuff, the delivery services even do not know how to handle it anymore. It is a tremendous danger for local industry, it is very bad for the environment. Do some online research, you will be impressed with the impact of these cheap products literally flooding into the European Union.
Aren’t those same cheap products coming in through corporations that sell it under some brand at triple the cost?
The “local” industries have already been decimated by the big conglomerates which imported the same cheap Chinese stuff and sold it as a hilarious profit.
It’s not the same stuff, though. A lot of these products do not fulfill any product safety law. There have been lots tests of random products sold on these platforms, showing that many are unsafe and/or dangerous (just google). A business sourcing from China has to ensure that sold products are safe and fulfill legal requirements. And yes, for this “service” they charge higher prices, and sometimes even unjustifiedly.
Right in the article they cite the analysis has numbers on a few groups of products like protrction equipment, makeup, and whether they pass EU standards. 60%-something do not. That also means 30%-something pass EU standards. That’s a lot of quality cheap product. Of course as a consumer you can’t tell whether you’re getting something from the 35% pile or the 65% one. But that doesn’t detract from the point of a lot of the cheap stuff in the category is the same stuff when it comes to EU standards.
Here’s an anecdote - years ago I really wanted a magnetic USB cable. Being skeptical of AliExpress stuff, especially electrical, I found a North American brans called Volta. Bought a cable. Cost me CAD $20 or $30. Some time after, I was browsing AliExpress for some specialty ebike parts that aren’t imported in Canada, I took a look at the magnetic cables they got. After a few pages of results I found a suspiciously similar cable to the Volta sold by the manufacturer itself. $3-4 for a set with a few magnetic tips. Ordered one. Once it came, I meticulously compared it to the Volta. It was identical in every way. It even failed in the same weak spot after a couple of years of use as the Volta. So yeah, while not everything is the same, not everything is not the same either.
Side note - the AliExpress prices are not the low prices available in other cheaper Chinese domestic retailers. Stuff on AliExpress already has significant markups. Volta did not pay $3-4 for that cable. They prolly paid $0.50-1 if even that much. They made exorbitant profit.
USB cables are actually a great example of where finding a brand with a good name does matter. Lots of cheap cables don’t properly follow the spec and then people end up frying their steam deck or other hardware.
It’s not so bad for data transfer but a real issue when you’re using them for supplying more power for computers or other expensive devices.
Sure, go and buy the stuff if you want. Personally, I do not have the competence to know which products contain harmful chemicals, for instance. I am not questioning that a lot of products are badly made quality wise. I’m just saying that any European retailer / producer is legally responsible to ensure the product is safe and not harmful. And testing costs money, believe it or not. (Yes they carry out tests. I have worked for a large retailer)
Wouldn’t it be nice to have cheap, pocket mass spectrometers. 😅
But you will still be able to buy such products, but with an additional 3 euros, I don’t see anything changing in terms of safety
So basically they are flooding eu with like small pox blankets in the form of consumer products with like lead or whatever in them. While getting paid for it
Not sure what safety small plastic stuff or disposable fashion products need to pass to merit the extra prices
For clothing, some have been found to have significant amounts of heavy metals in their dyes. That said, as the article itself says - more than a third passes EU standards.
But a bike wrench? A torque meter? A portable oscilliscope? No issues there. Some of those things are simply prohibitively expensive from EU/NA brands and are still made in China. I had to diagnose a signaling issue on an ebike I built. Were it not for Hantek and AliExpress, I’d simply given up and unable to solve it.
Were it not for cheap Chinese tools I wouldn’t have been able to develop the skills to build ebikes at all. I’ve now built 5 so far. I could easily turn this into a (co-op) business if get shitcanned from my job.
Exactly my point.
And to clarify, I understand what the other posters are saying (against my argument) but I am just done with all the protections for corporate profit
I personally don’t buy much clothes or care about fashion but, like your example, I am very frequently buying tools or small repair parts that the corporations either refuse to provide (to force you to buy a brand new whatever) or make ridiculously expensive
And to clarify, I understand what the other posters are saying (against my argument) but I am just done with all the protections for corporate profit
Exactly on the same page. Paying these exorbitant markups is usually not even flowing to local labour. The distribution centres are staffed at close to minimum wage. The margins go to the top where they contribute to rising wealth inequality which makes us poorer year after year. Fuck that.
E: Also Frigidaire sold me a plastic drawer rail for my fridge, shitty injection molded part from a worn mold, a part they’ve been making for decades, no more than cents to make, for CAD $60.
E2: If we’re gonna solve this for real by abandoning free trade as we know it, nationalizing the oligarchy’s wealth and reinvesting that in protected domestic industries that make most of what we need, paying wages that afford to buy that product, then I’ll be happy to be denied access to AliExpress and I’d be able to buy a CSA-certified Maple Electronics scope made in Windsor, ON. A few bucks on de-minimims - prolly won’t do it. Besides, it’s a regressive tax hitting the poorest most.
Kinda seems like a tax on the poor for being unable to afford better products.
You don’t get better products. You get products without safety testing, warranty or support. Clothes from some eastern brands have high amounts of chemicals that are forbidden in Europe because they cause cancer or infertility. Some type of escooter was banned in the UK some years ago because the dodgy electronics where responsible for multiple house fires. Iot devices or computers from some no name brand won’t get updates if a hacker finds exploits to mine Bitcoins on it, or spy on you and capture your logins from your cheap temu wifi router.
You should reread their comment, you agree with each other.
You are right, sorry. I did not have my coffee yet.
Can they put an exclusion for electronic components? 90% of the shit isn’t manufactured in the EU and local companies buy it from China and charge you 10x the price.
Should be specified that is not specific to Chinese imports, it’s to any import from any country outside of EU
In the meantime Chinese companies built warehouses in Europe, which are importing the cheap goods en grosse. You’re buying from a Chinese supplier, but the parcel is sent out from Europe.
Much more easy to regulate those. That’s kind of the point.
In the meantime Chinese companies built warehouses in Europe, which are importing the cheap goods en grosse.
They probably weren’t, at least for the things being described here, as the article is talking about de minimis.
The de minimis exception basically let low-value packages through without paying import tariffs.
There’s some reason to do that — it’d be more expensive to process the (many) low-value packages.
However, this also meant that if someone imported something in small, low-value amounts, they didn’t have to pay import tariffs, whereas people doing bulk imports did.
This was a major reason for the explosion of Chinese online retailers in the West, like Temu. They’d sell something that was shipped directly from China, which meant that they didn’t need to pay import tariffs on it. Traditional importers would import a large batch and would need to pay import tariffs, and then distribute the large batch from within the country in question, which penalized traditional retail.
ooo, i like you. de minimis is my favorite legal term
on the principle that’s fine, but it also means that DHL will add
6.50€7.50€ fees on top of that here in germany, which you can only pay in cash upon delivery, and they don’t even carry change.edit: it’s 7.50
As long as it helps stopping people from buying this Chinese stuff, I’m fine with it! Buy local, buy ecological, buy less but valuable and durable products.
Maybe it’s different in Europe, but in the US, my options are generally buy a Chinese-made product close to directly from the manufacturer via AliExpress or what have you or buy (often the same exact) a Chinese-made product through an American named big box store for 10x or even 25x the price.
Since Trump is in power, I do not particularly care about consumers suffering in the USA.
you completely missed the point they were making. It has absolutely nothing to do with consumers suffering in the US.
deleted by creator
For online stores that’s true, but the retailer is responsible for anything they sell in the US. There will still be some of that same junk, but a lot of those electronics are filtered out from retail because they aren’t certified.
Take a look at what kind of power strips are available online vs in a hardware store.
Buy local, buy ecological
Awesome, show me a local manufacturer who deals with speciality electronics and sensors and does them €3-4 apiece.
Did you ever wonder why these Chinese products are so cheap, and why they are not produced in Europe anymore? I think you should read up on this! First, the Chinese keep to Yuan artificially at a very low level. This is already unfair, and continues to boost their economy. Second, they subsidize most companies that export into other countries, to aggressively gain market share. Their workers work under poor conditions, and for that reason are cheap Labor (as you probably know, some are even slaves;-). So while you are happy to save a couple of bucks, people in the EU are loosing jobs and factories are closing down. I saw this happening with Japanese cars and electronics in the 70s and 80s. Whole industries disappeared.
95% of the product palette I use has literally no European alternative. Kinda hard to buy something that doesn’t exist.
Don’t worry, a local Corp will import it and sell it to you for 10x the price!
The Japanese cars, motorcycles and electronics were also miles better than what we produced here in the seventies. If anything it is an example that nothing is unbeatable forever. The Japanese didn’t kill the automotive industry in Europe. European cars and motorcycles instead got better and more desirable from the 80s on. And the Japanese electronics didn’t take over. Instead, European companies first upped their game as well, and later outsourced production to Eastern countries like China. Now that outsourcing is backfiring and European companies are once again challenged.
Why?
For example, i can order 25 $ Handguards for my bike, that are 100% identical to the original part, which costs 120 €
I’m with you on certain things, but some companies just make a lot of money with overprizing
Am I missing something? The original costs 125 (why do you mention $, in the EU we pay in €??). Now you buy them for 25+3+6, so you still make a profit of 91? This new tax is not to prohibit you from buying Chinese. It’s intended to stop the flow of cheap products coming in, which is eroding European industry at a rapid pace. The choice is yours, do you want to protect our EU industry, or do you want to surrender all jobs China?
It will do absolutely nothing to stop people from buying Chinese stuff, it’s just a stupid cash grab. The only ones benefiting are whoever collects the fee and companies importing Chinese goods on a large scale, as they can still offer them for basically the same price as before while individual imports get more expensive.
provided it’s something you can even buy here.
You are right, it is extremely hard nowadays to buy anything that has not been produced in China, or that does not contain at least one component from China. This should worry all of us, since it means that all production has moved to China, and factories in European Union are being closed down, and people lose their jobs because of this. This fee can only be the first step to rescue European production.
Even the European car factories and brands are now mostly Chinese owned.
Not true. Parcels can be delievered to DHL shop where you can pay with several methods (I already did so). Yet the fee is indeed annoying when comparing with the 3 € cause
how is what i said not true? i am telling what happens when it’s delivered to my door. i work from home and i’m always there, delivering to a shop is even worse
It not just per parcel, but per product category. Multiple categories in one parcel multiple times €3 customs.
Wonderful!
This can easily be bypassed by making group orders, don’t know if the Chinese sites will bother.
I import tea from China and Japan, wish there was good tea in Europe but that’s not the case and the nice stuff is absurdly overpriced or impossible to find, so I will not stop but I will do my best to avoid this stupid tax.
Great! So by your selfish need to get your tea cheap from abroad, you are perfectly willing to accept that local producers of tea have to close down their business, and people in European lose their jobs.
As someone who drinks quite a bit of tea Europe really doesn’t have great tea. Like oolongs and pu’er really just don’t grow here.
I mean if we keep up a perpetual heat wave and crank up humidity we might be able to do it, but as it stands we don’t have the climate (yet)
It’s not selfishness. It’s just agriculture.
€3 sounds to me too low to matter.
I know several people who buy crap from Shein and Temu - 3€ will definitely help.
